![[ANIME REVIEWS]](/file/35716/EX CD Rom.iso/issue2_8/images/section_anime.gif)
 |

 |
 |

— by Charles McCarter
Gau is a reluctant warrior, always wanting to know why people fight. His
adoptive sister Ella does it for the "thrill" and the honor, but somehow
that's not enough for Gau. As he and his sister journey back to his
hometown to visit his parents' graves, his fighting skill, beliefs, and
spirit are tested. And Gau must continue his attempts to learn the elusive
Shadow Skill.
If
you think this sounds very STREET FIGHTER-esque,
you're not alone. Except that Gau is more whiny than any of the SF characters. But then again, if all that happened to
one is continuously getting the tar beaten out of you, I suppose that would
give one reason to be unhappy. The first video pretty much goes from
fight to fight. Gau must fight Ella to develop his skills, then he must
fight an enemy when they are ambushed on the road. Then still later he
must fight Ella again, even after being severely wounded.
And
Ella apparently didn't read any Dr. Spock or Miss Manners, because when
she fights Gau, the blood really flows. A lot of red paint was used in the
making of this video. What a loving family this is.
Although
the plot for Part I is, to put it mildly, thin, the action sequences are
beautifully animated and very well choreographed. Fans of the
action/fighting genre will no doubt enjoy the well-executed fight scenes.
The rest of the show, however, is something of a mixed bag. The dubbed
voices sound awkward—sometimes they even seem to spontaneously develop
British accents for brief periods which then disappear. And the dialog is
less than sparkling; but then again, SHADOW SKILL
makes no pretense at being "smart" anime.
And
the plot has holes in it too. The "Shadow Skill" is a secret way of
fighting that Gau must learn; but no one is really clear on what it is until
Gau is nursed back to health by Scarface, the legendary warrior. He
explains the origins of the Shadow Skill. And after that scene, he, and
Ella, and Gau just go on about it like it was no big deal and everyone knew
all about its origins.
For
all its problems, though, the first volume looks brilliant compared to
the second. Volume Two plays like a release of three separate 1/2 hour OVAs
that are strung together, complete with opening narration. This time,
however, the focus is on the earlier days and how Ella and Gau met their
traveling companions Quo and Fowari, who had minuscule and unimportant roles
in the first volume.
The
most noticeable difference in the two volumes is the lack of fighting
sequences in the second volume. Instead of the fast-paced intense battles
of Volume One, the fights seem to be a slower, more casual affair, or they
are large melees with very little close-ups of combat. And there is less
fighting and more exposition.
The
character designs have also changed. Volume One has very sleek, sharp
designs done by Yamashita Toshinari. Volume Two has designs by Matsuo Shin
and they look very different. Matsuo uses a lot of thick, heavy lines,
giving his characters a gaunt appearance, and Gau especially does not look
as powerful. And finally, Matsuo has succumbed to the sideburns fad that
continues to plague recent anime, as Ella's sideburns look like handlebars
from a Harley Davidson.
Volume
Two feels like an attempt to go back and retrofit a story onto the
first SHADOW SKILL, but the characters behave too
inconsistently for it to be successful. And again, the voice acting is
about average for dubs these days, which doesn't mean very much.
SHADOW SKILL is another in a seemingly endless line of
fighting anime that is being released in the United States. Volume One
has some very good combat scenes, high-quality animation, and good
character designs. Volume Two, unfortunately, does not. Give SHADOW SKILL a try if fighting anime is your favorite
genre. Otherwise, move on to something else.
|
SHADOW SKILL
Copyright © 1995 Okada Megumu/"Shadow Skill" Production Committee,
Manga Entertainment, Inc.
Licensed to Manga Entertainment, Inc.
English Version Copyright © 1997 Manga Entertainment, Inc.
Volume 1
45 minutes
440 045 727-3
English Dubbed
$19.95
|
|
 |